Cellar Door Score
  • Home
  • About
  • Country
    • Australia >
      • New South Wales >
        • Canberra District >
          • Helm Wines
          • Mount Majura Vineyard
          • Eden Road Wines
          • Shaw Vineyard Estate
          • Clonakilla
          • Lark Hill
        • Hunter Valley >
          • Bimbadgen Estate
          • Hungerford Hill
          • Margan
          • Mount Pleasant
          • Audrey Wilkinson
          • Tempus Two
          • Usher Tinkler Wines
          • Pepper Tree Wines
          • Tulloch
          • Allandale Winery
          • Brokenwood
          • First Creek
          • Gundog Estate
          • Meerea Park
          • McGuigan Wines
          • Thomas Wines
          • Lake's Folly
          • Hope Estate
        • Orange >
          • Philip Shaw
          • Angullong
          • Ferment. The Orange Wine Centre
          • Brangayne of Orange
          • Colmar Estate
          • Patina
          • De Salis Wines
          • Ross Hill
          • Printhie
          • Slow Wine Co
      • South Australia >
        • Barossa >
          • Chateau Tanunda
          • Penfolds
          • Henschke
        • Clare Valley >
          • Knappstein
          • Skillogalee
        • Coonawarra >
          • Rymill
          • Balnaves of Coonawarra
          • Katnook Estate
          • Wynns Coonawarra Estate
          • Koonara
          • Ottelia
          • Penley Estate
          • Raidis Estate
          • Hollick Coonawarra
          • Brands Laira
          • Leconfield Wines Coonawarra
          • Majella Wines
          • Parker Coonawarra Estate
          • The Blok Estate
          • Yalumba Menzies Wine Room Coonawarra
          • Zema Estate
        • McLaren Vale >
          • D'Arenberg
          • Foggo Wines
          • Wirra Wirra
      • Tasmania >
        • Tamar Valley >
          • Josef Chromy
          • Delamere Vineyard
          • Bay of Fires Wines
          • Jansz
          • Sharmans Wines
          • Sinapius
          • Brook Eden
          • Pipers Brook Vineyard
        • East Coast >
          • Gala Estate
          • Devils Corner
          • Ironhouse Brewery
          • Milton Vineyard
          • Freycinet Vineyards
          • Darlington Vineyard
          • Spring Vale Wines
        • Coal River Valley >
          • Frogmore Creek
          • Riversdale Estate
          • Clemens Hill
          • Puddleduck Vineyard
          • Craigow
          • Pressing Matters
          • Every Man and His Dog Vineyard
          • Pooley Wines
          • Wicked Cheese
          • Coal Valley Vineyard
        • Derwent Valley >
          • Moorilla
          • Stefano Lubiana
          • Derwent Estate
        • Southern Tasmania >
          • Bangor Vineyard Shed
          • Bream Creek
      • Victoria >
        • Alpine Valleys >
          • Feathertop Winery
          • Ringer Reef
          • Billy Button
        • Bendigo >
          • Balgownie Estate Bendigo
          • Sandhurst Ridge
          • Killiecrankie
          • Connor Park
          • Harcourt Valley
          • Water Wheel
          • Suggested Bendigo Itinerary
        • Geelong >
          • Scotchmans Hill
          • Terindah Estate
          • Oakdene
          • Shadowfax
          • Bellbrae Estate
          • Basils Farm
          • Mt Duneed Estate
          • Leura Park Estate
          • Bellarine Estate
          • Jack Rabbit
          • Suggested Geelong Itinerary
        • Heathcote >
          • Merindoc
          • Silver Spoon Estate
          • Sanguine Estate
          • Tellurian
          • Munari Wines
          • Domaine Asmara
          • Heathcote II
          • Suggested Heathcote Itinerary
        • King Valley >
          • Chrismont
          • Dal Zotto Wines
          • Sam Miranda
          • Pizzini Wines
          • Brown Brothers
          • Gracebrook Vineyards
          • La Cantina
          • Milawa Cheese Factory
        • Macedon Ranges >
          • Curly Flat
          • Passing Clouds
          • Cloud 9 Farm
          • Paramoor
          • St Anne's Vineyards
          • Cobaw Ridge
          • Glen Erin Lancefield
          • Granite Hills
          • Hanging Rock Winery
          • Zig Zag Rd
        • Mornington Peninsula >
          • Polperro by Even Keel
          • Port Phillip Estate
          • Stonier
          • Willow Creek Vineyard
          • Yabby Lake
          • Morning Sun
          • Manton's Creek Estate
          • Montalto
          • Paringa Estate
          • Quealy Winemakers
          • T'Gallant
          • Lindenderry Wines
          • Paradigm Hill
          • Ten Minutes by Tractor
          • Crittenden Estate
          • Eldridge Estate
          • Merricks Creek
          • Merricks General Wine Store
          • Ocean Eight
          • Red Hill Estate
          • Tuck's Ridge
          • Foxeys Hangout
          • Suggested Itineraries Mornington Peninsula
        • Nagambie Lakes >
          • Mitchelton
          • Tahbilk Winery
        • Rutherglen >
          • All Saints Estate
          • St Leonards
          • Pfeiffer Wines
          • Campbells of Rutherglen
          • Jones Winery and Vineyard
          • Cofield
          • Lake Moodemere Estate
          • Rutherglen Estates
          • Stanton & Killeen
          • Anderson Winery
          • Valhalla Wines
          • The Wicked Virgin & Calico Town Wines
          • Buller Wines
        • Strathbogie Ranges >
          • Wine By Sam
          • Fowles Wine
        • Yarra Valley >
          • Levantine Hill
          • Oakridge
          • Immerse
          • De Bortoli
          • Innocent Bystander
          • Helen's Hill
          • Coombe Farm
          • Soumah
          • Yering Station
          • Many Hands Winery
          • Medhurst
          • Seville Estate
          • Sutherland Estate
          • Elmswood Estate
          • Giant Steps
          • Chandon
          • Mandala Wnes
          • Tarrawarra Estate
          • Helen & Joey Estate
          • Squitchy Lane
          • Tokar Estate
          • Fergusson Winery
          • Rochford Wines
          • Yarrawood
          • Coldstream Hills
          • Shantell Vineyard
          • St Huberts
          • Punt Road
          • Dominique Portet
        • Other Regions >
          • Delatite Wines
          • Djinta Djinta Winery
      • Western Australia >
        • Margaret River >
          • Ashbrook Estate
          • Brookland Valley
          • Cape Mentelle
          • Cullen Wines
          • Evans & Tate
          • McHenry Hohnen
          • Hayshed Hill
          • Juniper Estate
          • Laurance
          • Lenton Brae
          • Pierro
          • Stella Bella
          • Vasse Felix
          • Voyager Estate
          • Wills Domain
          • Windows Estate
          • Wise Wine
          • Xanadu Wines
    • France >
      • Champagne >
        • Champagne G Tribaut
        • J. De Telemont
        • JM Gobillard & Fils
        • Haton & Fils
        • Sourdet-Diot
        • Douard Christian
        • Moet & Chandon
        • Maison Veuve Clicquot
      • Burgundy >
        • William Fevre
        • Olivier LeFlaive
        • Domaine Chapuis
        • Domaine Yves Boyer Martenot
        • Domaine Patrick Javillier
        • Domaine Michel Voarick
      • Beaujolais >
        • Espace des Brouilly
        • La Maison des Beaujolais
        • Domaine de Tante Alice
        • Cave de Fleurie
      • Côtes du Rhone >
        • Cave du Verger des Papes
        • Chateau Mont Redon
        • Domaine la Boutinere
      • Bordeaux >
        • Château Lamothe Bergeron
        • Château Siran
        • Château Giscours
        • Château Brane-Cantenac
        • Château Coutet
        • Chateau Dauzac
        • Château du Tertre
        • Château Lanessan
        • Château Léoville Poyferré
        • Chateau Mouton Rothschild
        • Château Pontet Canet
    • Italy >
      • Tuscany >
        • Castello di Verrazzano
        • Castello Vicchiomaggio
        • Il Palazzone
      • Conegliano-Valdobbiadene >
        • Zardetto
        • Merotto Col San Martino
        • Sorelle Bronca
      • Soave >
        • Ca'Rugate
        • Cantina di Soave
        • Cantina Coffele
      • Valpolicella >
        • Azienda Agricola CORTE ALEARDI
        • Speri Viticoltori
        • Tommasi Viticoltori
      • Piedmont >
        • Tenute Cisa Asinari dei Marchesi di Grésy
    • Japan >
      • Yamanashi >
        • Haramo Wine
        • Grace Wine
        • Chateau Katsunuma
    • New Zealand >
      • Central Otago >
        • Amisfield
        • Misha's Vineyard
        • Mount Edward
        • Wooing Tree Vineyard
        • Brennan
        • Wet Jacket
        • Akarua
        • Aurum
        • Chard Farm
        • Peregrine
        • Mt Rosa
        • Rockburn
        • Scott Base
        • Carrick
        • Quartz Reef
        • Waitiri Creek
      • Hawkes Bay >
        • Craggy Range
        • Elephant Hill
        • Mission Estate Winery
        • Askerne
        • Black Barn Vineyards
        • Clearview Estate Winery
        • Vidal
        • Beach House
        • Te Awa Winery
        • Church Road Winery
        • Esk Valley Estate
        • Te Mata Estate
        • Trinity Hill
      • Kumeu >
        • Soljans Estate Winery
        • Coopers Creek
        • Westbrook
        • Kerr Farm Vineyard
        • Kumeu River
        • Twin Totara
      • Waiheke Island >
        • Cable Bay Vineyards
        • Mudbrick Vineyard
        • Man O' War
        • Te Whau Vineyard
        • Batch Winery
        • Goldie Estate
        • Jurassic Ridge
        • Kennedy Point Vineyard
        • Miro Vineyard
        • Obsidian
        • Passage Rock
        • Peacock Sky Vineyard
        • Poderi Crisci
        • Stonyridge Vineyard
        • Te Motu Vineyard
      • Wairarapa >
        • Tirohana Estate
        • Cambridge Road
        • Margrain Vineyard
        • Martinborough Vineyard
        • Palliser Estate
        • Schubert
        • Alana Wines
        • Haythornthwaite
      • Other New Zealand >
        • Mills Reef Winery
        • Mercury Bay Estate
    • North America >
      • Niagara Peninsula >
        • Tawse Winery
      • Hawaii >
        • Maui Wine
    • Portugal >
      • Douro Valley (including Porto) >
        • Quinta do Seixo
        • Graham's
        • Quinta do Bomfim
        • Quinta Nova
        • Quinta do Tedo
        • Ramos Pinto
        • Casa de Santo Antonio Britiande
        • Cockburn's
        • Quinta do Pego
        • Caves Vale do Rodo
        • Murganheira
        • Quinta de Sao Domingos
        • Vasques de Carvalho
        • Suggested Douro Valley Itinerary
    • Spain >
      • Jerez >
        • Bodegas Fundador
        • Bodegas Osborne
        • Sandeman
        • Groupo Estevez
        • Bodegas Tradicion
        • Bodegas Grant
      • Penedes >
        • Codorniu
        • Cava Guilera
        • Freixenet
        • Torres
        • Jean Leon
        • Suggested Penedes Itinerary
      • Rias Baixas >
        • Martin Codax
        • Pazo Senorans
        • Gil Armada
        • Lagar de Costa
        • Pazo Quinteiro da Cruz
        • Bodegas del Palacio de Fefinanes
        • Suggested Rias Baixas Itinerary
      • Ribeiro and Ribeira Sacra >
        • Vina Costeira
        • Ponte da Boga
        • Regina Viarum
      • Rioja >
        • Bodegas Baigorri
        • Ramon Bilbao
        • Marques de Riscal
        • C.V.N.E.
        • La Rioja Alta, S.A.
        • Muga
        • R. Lopez de Heredia
        • Ysios Winery
        • Gomez Cruzado
        • Izadi
        • Roda
        • Remirez De Ganuza
        • Bodegas Valdelana
        • Suggested Rioja Itinerary
      • Somontano >
        • Laus
        • Vinas del Vero
        • Bodega Pirineos
        • Sommos
        • Bodegas Lalanne
        • Suggested Somontano Itinerary
    • Other Countries
  • Awards
    • Australian Cellar Door Awards
    • French Cellar Door Awards
    • Italian Cellar Door Awards
    • New Zealand Cellar Door Awards
    • Portuguese Cellar Door Awards
    • Spanish Cellar Door Awards
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Membership
    • Membership Sign Up
    • Members Home Page >
      • Tips & Tricks >
        • Top Ten Tips When VIsiting a Cellar Door
        • Top Ten Packing Essentials for your Wine & Dine Holiday
  • Search
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture

About Us

Hello and thanks for visiting our site.  Our names are Megan and Michael and we are a couple that have shared a keen interest in wine since Megan started working in the wine industry in 2005.  Over the past 14 years, we have visited (purely in the name of research, of course....) all of the wine regions in Australia, New Zealand and France as well as the majority of regions in Italy, North America, Spain and Portugal clocking up visits to over 600 cellar doors.  We certainly aren't claiming to be wine experts, we'll leave that to the likes of Halliday and Parker, but what we did notice on our travels was that there was no real "one stop shop" for advice or independent reviews of the overall cellar door experience at the many, and varied, cellar doors around the world. 

We therefore decided to start this site (putting all of that laborious research to use) where we will share our experience at the cellar door and provide our rating based upon a number of criteria that we have found useful, rather than purely just an opinion on the quality of the wine.  That said, one of the criteria we will share is "How many bottles we purchased", which will be an indication of how much we liked the wine (noting that we always like to buy at least one bottle from every place we visit to thank the owners for welcoming us, although sometimes this may not be possible when travelling overseas!)  Where applicable, we will also make observations about the food offering, food being another of our passions, but again this will be just one component of the experience. 

We will also share with you some of our tips and photo's of the regions and cellar doors, to try and help you get a sense and feel of the places we are describing and ultimately rating and hopefully help you to navigate through the countless cellar door options across some of the world's greatest wine regions. 

About Our Ratings

Our ratings systems is based upon a number of criteria that we found important to our experience in addition to certain things we observed which we felt may be useful to others.  These criteria are set out on each of the individual cellar door review pages.  We should highlight that our review is purely based upon the experience we had on that particular day (or an average of our experiences if we have visited more than once) and therefore it is possible that the experiences of others will be different to the one we had (I guess we will just need to tough it out and visit them all again to confirm our observations!!)  All of the reviews are solely undertaken by the two of us, ensuring consistency of views across the board, although other visitors are welcome to share their own experiences in the comments section of each page on our site.

Based upon these criteria, we have then awarded our experience a "Cellar Door Score" (out of 20), of which up to 10 points relates to staff and overall service, 6 points for setting, atmosphere and comfort and 4 points for value, complementary offerings and range of appeal. 

For those that were the most highly rated based upon all of the criteria, we have awarded them a "Cellar Door", with 3 Cellar Doors being the highest rating awarded. 

Cellar Door Scores

10       Satisfactory                     
11       Reasonable                     
12       Solid                                 
13       Good                                    
14       Very Good                         
15       Great                                   
16       Excellent                            


16
17
17
18
19
20
Picture


Marvelous, an excellent tasting and more
Superb, all-round experience
Outstanding, worth a special trip
Brilliant, one of the best
Exceptional, an unforgettable experience
Best of the best, a must do that has it all

While there are a number of factors that go into determining whether a "Cellar Door" is awarded, the level of award can be broadly defined as follows:
  • 1 Cellar Door - the cellar door has an outstanding cellar door host/team, broad ranging appeal and a very high level and standard of complementary offerings and facilities
  • 2 Cellar Doors - the cellar door offers all that of a ”1 door” cellar door, but has a greater level of the complementary offerings and facilities under consideration
  • 3 Cellar Doors - the cellar door offers all that of a ‘2 door’ cellar door, but has all of the complementary offerings and facilities under consideration and also has something unique or unforgettable (i.e., a real “wow” factor) that sets it apart from other cellar doors and makes it a destination in itself

We also offer a "hidden gem" award to those cellar doors that have something unique or special to offer but don't necessarily have all of the complementary offerings to achieve a door rating.  Keep an eye out for Dom in our ratings and he might just guide you to a few hidden gems!

As we continue to visit new cellar doors around the world, or revisit some of our favourites, we will update this site with our reviews, so be sure to check in every now and again or keep an eye out for our alerts on various social media (or via direct updates for subscribers).
We have also introduced some quick reference icons to help you narrow down your desired cellar door by region.  Our new quick reference icons are:
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Cellar door caters well to large bus group

Cellar door has a fireplace

Cellar door has a food offering

Cellar door provides free tastings

Cellar door has toys, etc for kids

Cellar door is dog friendly
We hope you enjoy!

Please note: Bottle price range quoted is for 750ml bottles in local currency for consistency and approximate delivery costs refer to delivery within the cellar door's home country.  Also, whilst we endeavour to ensure administrative information such as opening times, credit cards accepted, etc are as accurate as possible, we suggest you refer to the wineries own website (linked through the heading of each page) to confirm this information if you are planning a visit.
Fast Cover Travel Insurance
Luxury Rental Cars
© 2015 Cellar Door Score All Rights Reserved
Glen Iris, Victoria, Australia
About    Contact    Terms of Use       Privacy  Advertise with Us